“The Baptism of a Jewish Boy”
A Reflection by Leslie Buerschaper – January 9, 2023
On May 15, 1927, a baby boy was born in Herford, Germany to a Christian mother and a
Jewish father. It is important to note here that by Jewish law, a baby is only Jewish if born of a Jewish mother. Despite family tradition, the boy’s mother decided not to have the baby baptized.
Now this baby lived with his mother, father, his mother’s three sisters, and their husbands, in the hotel the baby’s maternal grandparents owned and operated. One of the boy’s uncles was particularly upset with his sister-in-law’s decision to not baptize his nephew. So, one night, the uncle snuck the infant out of their home and took him down the street to the family church. The minister was waiting for them and, in secret, baptized the baby.
Unlike the secret baptism of the baby boy with the Jewish father, the baptism of Jesus
was a more public event. Matthew 3 verse 5-6 says this: “Then Jerusalem and all Judea and all the region around the Jordan were going out to him, 6and they were baptized by him in the River Jordan, confessing their sins.” John was following the ancient Jewish practice of baptism: a practice of ritual bathing or cleansing. The Hebrew word for ritual bathing is Mikveh. Mikveh has many meanings depending on the context. It can mean something waited for, a collection of water, a caravan, gathering together, hope or pool of water. In Jeremiah 17 we are told that God is the Mikveh of Israel and that those who turn away from God will be dried out. The practice of ritual cleansing performed by John was a practice of renewing one’s relationship with God, or in simple terms, turning back to God. When Jesus came to his cousin John to be baptized, John didn’t want to do, he didn’t feel worthy. John argues that Jesus should be baptizing him. John is steering us to the fact that Jesus is not the typical candidate for baptism.
We learn about the baptism of Jesus in all three of the synoptic Gospels. Matthew, Mark
and Luke all tell us that John baptized Jesus in the river Jordan. These three Gospels also tell us that after the Baptism, the Heavens opened up, the Holy Spirit came down like a dove and God said “this is my son and I am well pleased.” Matthew, however, is the only gospel that has the brief conversation between John and Jesus. Jesus says to John “Let it be so now, for it is proper for us in this way to fulfill all righteousness.” Why is this? Scholars believe that Luke’s audience was Gentiles, Mark’s Gentile converts, predominantly in Rome, but Matthew’s Gospel was geared to a Jewish audience and baptism was a ritual of the Jewish people at the time. Does Matthew suspect his readers may believe Jesus needs to be cleansed of sin? Maybe. Or is Matthew showing that John is obeying God and paving the way for God’s proclamation: “this is my son.” These words from God dispel any question as to who Jesus is. The baptism also places Jesus at the same starting point as the people he has come to save.
Six years after the boy with the Jewish father was secretly baptized, Adolf Hitler gained
power. Information quickly began to flow about the Nazi’s plans for the Jewish people. The baby boy was now six and his father began to panic. He secured passage for his family to San Francisco. It was time for the boy’s uncle to reveal his secret. He told the boy’s parents about the secret baptism and gave them the baptism certificate. As a result, the boy’s mother refused to leave Germany and her family. She believed her son was safe. The boy’s father moved to San Francisco and never saw his family again. The family believed the boy’s baptism had literally saved his life.
In 1943, Nazi authorities declared that Germany had been cleansed of the Jewish people
and they temporarily halted deportation to concentration camps. At this time, fewer than 20,000 Jewish people remained in Germany. Some were in hiding, others were not deported “because race laws classified them as of mixed ancestry, or part Jewish.” , like the boy with the Jewish father. The word to note here is temporarily.
At some point the boy with the Jewish father was placed on the Registration of
Foreigners and German Persecutes list. His reference number was 5532001 and his document ID was 70662095. Sometime in early 1944, the SS stormed into the family home and took the now 16-year-old boy. The family resisted and presented the boy’s baptism certificate. It was dismissed. The boy was seized, put on a train and transported to a concentration camp.
Although often at odds with each other, the German Christian movement had a strong
role to play in the Nazi’s plan to create the perfect Arian race. Churches of the German Christian movement provided baptism records of children, their parents and grandparent to prove that they were Christian. However, if both maternal and paternal grandparents were not baptized, children were put on the Registration of Foreigners and German Persecutes list even if the children themselves had been baptized. It was the belief of the German Christian movement that baptism did not , and I quote, “change the status of a Jew...baptism could not make a Jew a German.. and baptism could not make a Jew a Christian.”
Another one of the boy’s uncles was a personal chef for a Nazi colonel. This uncle
learned of his nephew’s detainment and forged papers to secure his release. He took the boy home and put him in to hiding where he stayed until the end of the war. The uncle was caught and sentenced to fight within one of the Nazi’s penal battalions in Poland at the Russian front.
He was captured and sent to a labor camp in Russia. Somehow, he escaped and made his way home. When he arrived, he weighed a mere 85 pounds. In 1951, the uncle moved his family to Canada and never saw the nephew he saved again. That baptized Jewish boy was my dad’s cousin: the uncle that saved him, my beloved grandfather.
It is likely that our own baptism experience was very different from the boy with the
Jewish father’s. The reasons for his baptism are also likely very different.
Jesus’ baptism experience was also very different from our own experience. Jesus’
baptism mirrors the prophecy of Isaiah that we heard in the Isaiah reading today: “Here is my servant, whom I uphold, my chosen, in whom my soul delights; I have put my spirit upon him; he will bring forth justice to the nations.” And although God’s Spirit descended like a dove and alighted on him, we know Jesus was from the Spirit, he did not receive it.
The moment of baptism for Jesus was the recognition that he was chosen:
chosen to teach, chosen to serve faithfully, chosen to be in community, chosen to create a
disciple family, chosen to advance justice and equality, chosen for his time, chosen for our time.
The moment of baptism or confirmation for Christians is the recognition of a calling to God, through Jesus and the Holy Spirit. A calling to us to teach, serve faithfully, be in community, create a disciple family, to advance justice and equality in our time.
May it be so.