Sunday, May 7th, 2023 – Coronation Sunday
Philip’s Reflection: “Lord, show us the Father” (Jn. 14:8)
You may have noticed that there’s been some discussion in recent months about the
title of the new King of Canada - “Defender of the Faith” or “Defender of Faith” (of all
faiths) - what is King Charles the “Defender” of? Some of you may remember the uproar
– particularly in the Church of England – when, as Prince of Wales 30 or more years
ago, Charles mused publicly about the possibility of changing the coronation oath, to be
the defender of faith in general, rather than the defender of the faith, the faith tradition of
the Church of England. His desire of course was to embrace all religious traditions in a
multifaith Britain – for, as the latest census data show, less than half the population of
England and Wales (46%) now identify as “Christian”; under 1% of the population attend
Sunday worship; and the fastest growing segment, up 12% over the past 10 years, are
those describing themselves as having “no religion” – the numbers are similar in
Canada. What is the relevance of an oath to defend the Faith, when less than half the
population consider themselves Christians and over a third believe in no deity at all?
One way of resolving this is the “Canadian way”, which might best be described as
“when in doubt, leave out”. If you can’t agree on a title, rather than include any
reference to the monarch’s role as the defender of faith, you just quietly drop it – you
bury it deep inside a Budget Bill, as was done recently by the Federal Government,
such that the monarch’s title no longer includes the “defender” role or any reference to
Charles’ Christian faith. Oh well! We must be grateful, I suppose, that his official title, as
our Head of State, still includes a mention of God, for he is to be known as “Charles the
Third, by the Grace of God, King of Canada”.
As you saw and heard in yesterday’s historic Coronation service, King Charles decided
in fact to say the Coronation Oath without changing the centuries-old commitment to
defend the Faith, apparently in deference to the British monarch’s role as the “supreme
governor” of the Church of England, the Established Church in Britain. But that is not a
role King Charles exercises in Canada, or other Commonwealth nations, and I don’t
think we have any difficulty with dropping the title of Defender of the Faith in Canada.
But it’s disappointing that we no longer describe his role as Defender of Faith (of all
faiths) because, as you probably noticed yesterday, King Charles included (for the first
time) a prayer “that I may be a blessing to all thy children, of every faith and belief, that
together we may discover the ways of gentleness and be led into the paths of peace” –
all God’s children, of “every faith and belief”. And you’ll have seen and heard of many
other signs of King Charles’ belief, as he said in a reception for faith leaders at
Buckingham Palace last September, that the sovereign has a “duty to protect the
diversity of our country, including by protecting the space for faith itself and its practice
through the religions, cultures, traditions and beliefs to which our hearts and minds
direct us as individuals.” And then for emphasis – “By my most profound convictions ... I
hold myself bound to respect those who follow other spiritual paths, as well as those
who seek to live their lives in accordance with secular ideals.” It is very good news that
we have a king who respects all faiths and those who have none.
With the British Prime Minister, a practising Hindu, reading Paul’s letter to the
Colossians, which speaks to “the loving rule of Christ over all people and all things”, and
with Buddhist, Hindu, Jewish, Muslim, Sikh and other faith leaders taking leadership
roles in the coronation service, we can all be hopeful, I believe, that Canada’s monarch
and Head of State will become a unifying figure, a force for religious and cultural
tolerance and reconciliation, not only in the United Kingdom, but also here in Canada.
At St. David’s we too are committed to diversity and inclusion – it is a vision of a
“Changed World” and “Changed Lives” – one that recognizes and respects the wisdom
of other faiths and that, based on our experience, meaningful conversations with those
from other faith traditions also help us to deepen and grow our own faith.
With open hearts and open minds towards those from other faith traditions, how then
are we to interpret Jesus’ statement to Thomas, that we heard in today’s Gospel
reading? Thomas has said to Jesus, towards the end of the Last Supper, “Lord, we do
not know where you are going. How can we know the way?” (14:5) and Jesus replies
with one of the greatest of his “I AM” sayings – “I am the way and the truth and the life.
No one comes to the Father except through me.” (14:6). No one? Except through
Jesus? How does that sound to our friends at the Har El Synagogue across the
highway? And of course many contemporary Christians use this verse to claim that the
only way to “eternal life”, in this world or the next, is through Jesus – that there is no
room for God’s mystery to be revealed in other religious systems such as Islamic or
Jewish. Moreover, the statement is sometimes used out of context, as a threat, to
exclude and threaten – that “to be saved” you have to sign up, and accept Jesus as
your personal Lord and Saviour. Such an interpretation does violence to the spirit of
Jesus’ words. The disciples are profoundly unsettled – they’ve just had their feet
washed by their Lord, been told that he will be betrayed by some among them, and that
he will soon depart from them. They are full of questions and concerns – “How can we
know the way?” (asks Thomas) “Lord, show us the Father” (says Philip).
Jesus offers a word of comfort to the disciples - “Do not let your hearts be troubled.”
Trust in God, he says, trust also in me (14:1). There’s no need to panic – for Jesus
promises them that he himself is all they need – “if you know me, you will know my
father also” and so that there can be no misunderstanding “from now on you do know
him and have seen him.” For the disciples that evening, Jesus tells them that he is the
“way and the truth and the life” – to trust in him is to trust in the Father – to see Jesus is
to see the Father, for he is “in the Father and the Father is in me”. For the first disciples,
and for those of us in the faith today, Jesus provides the way - the way of being - to
reveal the goodness of the Father and, for followers of Jesus, he is our way. But this is
not to deny the existence or validity of other paths “up the mountain”, to experience the
divine reality of God, however expressed. Then, and even more so now, there are
multiple different paths up the mountain, sometimes the paths diverge and sometimes
they intersect, but all of them are capable of leading to the “top of the mountain”- one
truth, the divine presence, the ultimate reality. For us as Christians, that reality is the
Father, whose unconditional love is revealed by the Beloved Son – and the path to the
Father is offered through the Son.
The historic message of yesterday’s Coronation is that all of these paths are valued. We
all start in a context that reflects our upbringing or faith journey, often a long and
winding road to where we are today – in King Charles’ case as a committed Anglican:
all these paths have intense personal meaning to those who follow them, and all are to
be respected and welcomed – because diversity of race and culture and religious
expression are gifts from God, to be celebrated, not to be used as threats or
opportunities for wedge driving or exclusion. Today, we give God thanks for a monarch
who embraces religious diversity and inclusion; a monarch who defends and respects
all faiths and beliefs; and a monarch who is called to be a blessing and a servant of all
people, after the pattern of Christ Jesus, the Son of God, the Lord of all Lords, the King
of all Kings, Amen.