Sunday, October 17th, 2021 – Stewardship Sunday
Philip’s Reflection: “Giving Cheerfully” (2 Cor. 9:7)
We’ve designated today as “Stewardship Sunday” at St. David’s and it’s not by accident that we’ve chosen the Sunday immediately following Thanksgiving, to consider the meaning of stewardship because as we’ll be reflecting, there’s an important connection between stewardship and giving thanks to God. And although we’ll focus on “money matters” this morning we also understand stewardship in a broader sense because as so many in this community demonstrate each day, there are many other ways we can share our gifts. Some give generously of their time in support of voluntary programs, either here or in other organizations; others offer their gifts of experience, or advocacy or compassion, as many of you do, in support of those less fortunate than ourselves; others share their gifts of love and caring in ways that support each other, or that reflect environmental concerns or to confront poverty or injustice.
But today we’re going to focus on the narrower meaning of stewardship, financial stewardship, while recognizing that it’s part of the larger question of how we manage and (literally) how we act as stewards of the many gifts that bless our lives. And we acknowledge that these are very personal issues and it’s important to tell you that, as your minister, I do not know, and I don’t need to know, the level of your individual offerings; but I can tell you how profoundly grateful we are at St. David’s for your financial support, whatever the level. Many of you are on fixed incomes now and we are all faced with sharply rising costs, particularly in West Vancouver and there are so many other good causes, beyond St. David’s, that we give financially to, in support of those in need. So we take a moment to celebrate and thank all of you, particularly those who’ve maintained, or even increased, your gifts to St. David’s during the past 18 months.
What do our two New Testament readings today tell us about stewardship, and about giving to the Church? The first reading, from Mark’s Gospel, tells the familiar story of the “Widow’s mite” – “mite” being the smallest Jewish coin used in Jesus’ time. We first hear of Jesus scolding the “scribes” for their hypocrisy – they strut about in long robes, they get the best seats in the synagogue and they offer long prayers in public while “devouring”, perhaps expropriating, the homes of the most vulnerable. And then there’s this widow, financially destitute, who places two small coins in the offering plate and Jesus says that she has “put in more” than all those who have put in much larger sums.
We had a lively discussion about this passage in our Bible Study group this Wednesday and the conclusion we came to was that its meaning wasn’t only about the size of her contribution relative to her income or savings – “she put in everything she had, all she had to live on”; or even, purposely, to contrast her actions with the gifts of the rich – “who have contributed out of their abundance.” Yes, Jesus commends her sacrificial giving. But we think this story is really about her motivation – perhaps even her inner joy. We picture this poor woman standing there, dignified, a model of humble faithfulness, as she offers God all that she has – and more. We might say that the wealthy scribes give showingly from their abundance; while the poor woman gives glowingly from her heart. Let’s hold onto that image.
Our second reading, Paul’s 2nd letter to the Corinthian church, also concerns the motives for giving. Paul is organizing a collection, fund-raising, from the Gentile churches that he will take to Jerusalem to distribute among the Jewish poor and he’s asking the Corinthians to dig deep. He’s told them how other Gentile churches have already stepped up and contributed to the collection, despite their extreme poverty. And now we want you, he tells the Corinthians, who “excel in everything – in faith, speech, in knowledge” etc. to excel in your generosity. No pressure, says Paul, “I don’t say this as a command, but I’m testing the genuineness of your love against the earnestness of others.” And, if this still doesn’t convince them he appeals to the Gospel message of Christ’s sacrificial giving – “You know the generous act of our Lord Jesus Christ, yet though he was rich, for your sakes he became poor, so that by his poverty you might become rich” (9:9). Last year, Paul says, you indicated your support – “now finish doing it… complete it according to your means. For if the eagerness is there, the gift is acceptable according to what one has – not according to what one does not have.” He might have put it in these terms - you don’t have to give everything away, as Jesus did, or even like that selfless widow – but give according to what you have. “Each of you must give as you have made up your mind, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.” (9:7). What does it mean to give cheerfully?
Let’s start with what Paul says is the point of his letter and it’s the metaphor of sowing and reaping - “the one who sows sparingly will also reap sparingly, and the one who sows bountifully will also reap bountifully” (9:6). At one level this is helpful, I feel – we know that, in many areas of our lives, the more fully we give, the more we will receive in return. But we must be careful not to stretch the metaphor too far, because we also know of the risks of over-giving, of becoming over-extended, with the result that we give ourselves away; and instead of the harvest growing proportionately with the sowing, we experience instead the law of diminishing returns. Some might disagree, but I don’t believe that God calls us to give everything away, including ourselves – that is not the message of the parable of the talents or even the invitation to “Come to me all who are weary and are carrying heavy burdens, and I will give you rest.” (Matt. 11:28). Paul tells the Corinthians to give “according to our means” and we must each determine the implications for our level of financial support.
Another problem we might have with “the more you sow the more you reap” metaphor, is if the size of the harvest becomes the motive for the amount that we sow. Yes, we all want our financial gifts to have as much impact as possible. But we don’t give bountifully in order to receive bountifully. We give because we have already received – we sow because we have already been blessed with a rich harvest, and in gratitude we give for the love we have already received; and we want to share these blessings with those less fortunate than ourselves. That’s what we mean by “paying it forward” – we give back to God by giving freely and generously to others, particularly to those in most need of our support.
God loves a cheerful giver, says Paul, one who gives in gratitude, without expecting anything in return - one who gives, like the widow, “glowingly” with a joyful heart, not in a transactional sense, not expecting to receive recognition or even God’s approval; but as an expression of love, in gratitude for the love and blessings that God – and also this community of friends – have already showered on us.
At the end of today’s reading, Paul tells us that God provides us “with every blessing in abundance, so that by always having enough of everything, you may share abundantly in every good work.” For many reasons, including a global pandemic, our annual receipted givings at St. David’s are down around 30% during the past 5 years; but so also are our expenses – largely the result, I might add, of a 50% decline in our budget for staff salaries and benefits. And the imaginative and effective use of our wonderful facilities has helped keep us solvent, with over 50% of our total income now contributed by our tenant partners. We are so grateful to all who have made this possible, including the Federal Government for its pandemic support programs and the ProVision Fund of the United Church that has financed our intercultural ministries.
Paul’s letter reminds us that, in our abundance, we are called to “share abundantly in every good work”. So let us do this cheerfully, knowing that God has provided us with every blessing and God always will. But a sustainable future for this community will require imagination, commitment, generosity and visionary leadership – and the good news is that all of these gifts are well-represented in the St. David’s community. Above all, if we are to stay and grow - it will require your ongoing financial support – and, God willing, the support of the newcomers who are such a blessing to this community.
I leave you with this final thought: as we presented the offering this morning, we sung these words to God – “We give you but your own, whate’er the gift may be; all that we have is yours alone, we give it gratefully.” The biblical understanding of stewardship is that God owns everything and that we are managers, stewards, of God’s creation, on God’s behalf. So, as we each reflect in the weeks ahead on our personal financial priorities, let us also remember, as we said in our Creed last week that – “We live in God’s world” – and we give back to God what God has already given us; we give because we have already received and we give from our abundance, gladly, cheerfully, in gratitude and thanksgiving for all that this community has offered in the past and for all it may become in the future, by the grace of God.