Sunday, January 23rd, 2022 – Christian Unity
Philip’s Reflection: “That All May Be One” (Jn 17:21)
The Week of Prayer for Christian Unity traditionally starts on the 18th of January, known
as the Feast of the Confession of Saint Peter, and ends on January 25th, the Feast of
the Conversion of Saint Paul, and if you think that sounds rather “catholic” you’d be
right, because this eight-day period was first proposed as an observance within the
Roman Catholic Church in 1908 and it was adopted by Protestant denominations, such
as the United Church of Canada in the 1960s.
Well, you might say, isn’t it a bit late to start praying for Christian unity? - because from
its earliest days, in the years immediately following the death and resurrection of our
Lord, the Church has experienced a history of rivalry and disunity, evidenced by
division, schisms and outright hostility between different branches of the universal
church, rather than cooperation and unity. It seems a bit ironic that Feast days
honouring Saints Peter and Paul should now bookend the Week for Christian Unity
given the tensions that existed even between these two great Apostles, and then
between the different communities that identified with each of them; then think of the
great theological controversies involving Arius and Athanasius in the 4th century, the
Great Schism between the Eastern Orthodox Christians and the Western churches in
the 11th century, Martin Luther’s 95 Theses and the Protestant Reformation of the 16th
Century and so on right down through the ages.
The Center for the Study of Global Christianity, a US-based Christian think-tank,
estimates that, in 2019, there were 45,000 Christian denominations globally – of which
the United Church of Canada is just one. You’ll be relieved that we’re not going to
explore all the factors that have contributed to this fragmentation. But the questions for
today are, in light of this history – is it too late to pray for, or even to expect, significant
progress towards ecumenism – towards unity among the world’s Christian
denominations; and more importantly, does Christian unity really matter – for the
worldwide church, for our denomination, or even for us here at St. David’s? Let’s turn to
our scripture readings for some answers.
Why should we care about Christian Unity? Our first reading, from the Gospel of John,
is an extract from Jesus’ final prayer for the disciples, and for future generations of
believers - Father, he prays, “I ask... that all may be one.” – the version of this in Latin
“Ut unum omnes sint” is on the crest of United Church of Canada. Jesus prays for unity
– as he is in the Father and the Father in him – “so that the world may believe that you
have sent me” (Jn 17:21). And Jesus repeats this request – “that they may be
completely one, so that the world may know that you have sent me and have loved
them even as you have loved me.” In other words, unity does matter, because being
one, or even being completely one, as Jesus says, is the evidence that God has sent
him into the world to love those who believed in him. A church that is “at one”, is
confident in its shared beliefs, and has one voice on important issues; a church that acts
together is a more effective church in proclaiming the Gospel to the world – of bearing
witness to God’s love for the world, than a fragmented church that is often quarrelsome
and at loggerheads, unable to get things done together.
The Apostle Paul in his famous metaphor of the Church as the body of Christ – says
that it’s baptism that is the unifying sign for all Christians – “we were all baptized into
one body.... We were all made to drink of one Spirit”. Paul acknowledges diversity
within the Church - in fact he celebrates it – because it was his vocation, his calling, to
bring the Good News of the gospel to the gentile world with all its languages, cultures
and social differences - “Jews or Greeks, slaves or free”. For Paul, the church offers a
vision of the final reconciliation of all things that God promises– a glimpse of the
kingdom of God. A church that is united by the power of the Holy Spirit, in baptism, is
evidence that what we all have in common, is far more important than what divides us.
All members of this body of Christ perform an equally valuable function and the whole
body is weakened if any of its members are pulling in different directions, or are no
longer attached to the body.
How do we reconcile these two passages with a worldwide church composed of 45,000
Christian denominations with major differences of theology, practice and worldview -
differences even within denominations? Firstly, it’s important that we don’t confuse unity
with uniformity. Jesus does not say that church members all need to look like each
other, or think the same, or worship the same way or even to have the same
understandings of God. Church would be a pretty dull place if they did! Paul suggests
the opposite in fact – diversity is not to be avoided, a problem to be solved, but a gift of
God’s grace in baptism, evidence that we all share the same water through the power of
the Holy Spirit. It is completely understandable, it seems to me, that different
denominations would express their calling in different ways for the different contexts in
which they are located, and the different communities they serve.
But as we’ve heard in both our readings this morning, we are more effective as the
Church, or as communities of faith, when we speak with one voice, when we act
together rather than against each other, even if we have different understandings of
Scripture, and different expressions of worship. And we lend our support to the ongoing
ecumenical work, both nationally and here in the Pacific Mountain Region, of bringing
our denominations closer together and as a United and Uniting church, we can play a
meaningful role in bringing the fragmented church in Canada into closer relationship. I
look forward to being part of that dialogue in future.
But it’s at the local level, here as a community of faith, at St. David’s, where we have
greatest opportunity to model the unity that Jesus, and Paul, call us into – as one body
of Christ, with a diverse membership, where each member is valued for the gifts that
she or he brings to the community, however those gifts are expressed or revealed. And
the way we will do this is the way that Jesus has commanded us – it is the way of love
for each other, for our neighbours, and for the world. As we know in other areas of our
lives, love does not always mean agreement – as I’ve said, unity does not mean
uniformity nor also does it mean unanimity – at least not all of the time! But it does
mean an attitude of mutual respect, humility, forgiveness, openness to the views and
traditions of the other, and care for all in our community, and all whom we welcome as
brothers and sisters in Christ. It means being intentionally open and hospitable to the
diverse neighbourhood in which we are located and which we serve. And it means
accepting that all in our community, sisters and brothers in Christ, are equally valued,
equally loved and equally empowered to shape the future of the beloved community.
“Christian Unity”, therefore, it seems to me, is best understood as a vision of a loving,
diverse and hospitable community committed to justice and right relationships with all of
God’s creation. It’s an inspiring vision and it’s one that together, for us here as St.
David’s United, will reveal God’s purpose for the church in the world, demonstrating, as
Jesus says, “that you [Father] have sent me, and have loved them, even as you have
loved me.”
And it’s that vision of Christian Unity, across all the churches in West Vancouver, in
Canada and across the world, that we pray for this week. May it be so.
Amen,
January 23rd, 2022