Sunday, November 6th, 2022 – Remembrance Sunday
Philip’s Reflection: “God of the Living and the Dead” (Luke 20:38)
In the United Church of Canada we traditionally designate the Sunday before November
11 as Remembrance Sunday.
And, as its name implies, we do remember and we remind ourselves again, and again
each year, of the sacrifices made by the men and women who came and served before
us, and the men and women who continue to serve Canada in times of war or conflict or
peace. And firstly, we honour them – the nearly 2.5 million Canadians who have served
throughout our nation’s history, and the more than 118,000 who made the ultimate
sacrifice. And the date of November 11, this Friday, is so significant each year, the
anniversary of the Armistice that ended WWI, and it’s the day that we will place these
wreaths at the Memorial Arch in West Vancouver, because more than half, 66,000, of
the Canadians who have died in the service of their country died in the 1st WW, one in
10 of all Canadians in uniform, remembering also a further 172,000 severely wounded,
often with dreadful, life-changing injuries, – in a war so bloody and brutal, so horrific and
wasteful of young lives, that it was described then as the “war to end all wars”. If only –
So we remember with deep gratitude; we give God thanks for the lives of all the men
and women who have served Canada, all our veterans and all who continue to serve in
uniform today; and we ask God to keep them safe, and to heal the wounded in mind or
body, that they may know the love and gratitude of the country they serve.
And we also remember with sadness, for we cannot help but feel a deep sorrow for the
destructive effects of war, and we need to be reminded of the sheer scale of human loss
in the two World Wars, and the disproportionate effect that all wars have on civilian
populations – you probably know that over half of the 41 million lives lost in WW1 were
civilians; in WWII, approximately 45 million of the 60 million fatalities, around three
quarters, were civilian women, children and men. The proportion of civilian casualties in
warfare is even higher today with cruise missiles and drones and all the dreadful effects
of precision guided missiles terrorizing civilian lives and destroying essential
infrastructure – and we also pay tribute to the brave men and women who place
themselves in harm’s way to report and document and record and remind us each day
of the terrible cost paid by innocent people caught in the grip of modern warfare.
In the days before live reporting from the front line, by radio or television, when
newspaper accounts and photography were delayed or heavily censored, it was the
War Poets, like John McRae and Marjorie Pickthall, who described and warned us of
the human cost of war in ways that still speak vividly to us, and continue to challenge us
100 or more years later. To be sure, the early war poetry reflected a mood of patriotic
idealism - but as the meaningless horror, brutality and foulness of the Western Front
stalemate in 1916 and 1917 began to be experienced and understood, a “reality” war
poetry emerged that captured the terror and the tragedy of modern warfare – of rat
infested, disease-ridden life in the trenches, the dreadful effects of heavy artillery and
above all the terrifying use of poison gas on poorly equipped soldiers. – hear these
words from Wilfred Owen’s poem of 1917 “Dulce et decorum est” -
Bent double, like old beggars under sacks,
Knock-kneed, coughing like hags, we cursed through sludge,
Till on the haunting flares we turned our backs,
And towards our distant rest began to trudge....
Gas! GAS! Quick, boys! - An ecstasy of fumbling
Fitting the clumsy helmets just in time,
But someone still was yelling out and stumbling
And flound’ring like a man in fire or lime
Dim through the misty panes and thick green light,
As under a green sea, I saw him drowning.
In all my dreams before my helpless sight,
He plunges at me, guttering, choking, drowning....”
And it’s from this tradition of truth telling, “tell it like it is” war poetry that the Canadian
soldier and physician Dr. John McRae emerged and it is a tribute to his honesty, as well
as the quality of his poetry, that “In Flanders Fields” has now become part of our
Remembrance tradition – and it will be read around the world this Friday – and to his
lasting credit McRae reminds us that there is nothing glorious or romantic about the
poppies blowing between the crosses, row on row, marking the shallow graves of tens
of thousands of dead Canadian soldiers.
And as you’ve heard this morning, Marjorie Pickthall, an extraordinary but
underappreciated Canadian female poet of that era, reminds us in a different way of the
terrible human cost of war and I will end this reflection this morning with her poem,
Marching Men, which has been a personal discovery, and a gift on this Remembrance
Sunday – for Pickthall places the sacrifice of Canadian lives in WWI in a Christian
context – she sees, in the endless lines of soldiers marching to war, “a thousand Christs
go by” – on their way to Calvary – who, like Christ, would make the ultimate sacrifice –
would give “their earth-born dreams to deck the grave” – so that “heaven might heal the
world”. And Pickthall ends her short poem with words that touch our hearts today, as
she reminds us, for each one of this “holiest fellowship” of young men, marching in
many cases to a certain death, that “far off, apart, seven swords have rent a woman’s
heart” – whether that heart be a mother’s, a sister, or a wife or lover.
I don’t know if Marjorie Pickthall knew of today’s Scripture reading in which Jesus is
challenged by those who did not believe in life beyond death; but I hope so, because it
would have brought her comfort – as it can do for us too, and for any whose lives, or the
lives of loved ones, are at risk. Jesus won’t be drawn on the question of which of the
seven brothers who died childless, or the woman they married, by tradition, would
participate in the resurrection – for “they cannot die anymore” says Jesus, “because
they are like angels and are children of God, being children of the resurrection.” For
God is God, says Jesus, “not of the dead but of the living, for to God all of them are
alive.” (Lk. 20: 38). All are children of the resurrection; all of them are alive with God.
This Remembrance Sunday, let us give thanks for the sacrifice of those who marched to
Calvary; we give thanks for the veterans who have returned home, and we give thanks
to those who continue to serve in uniform, serving their country and maintaining the
peace, whether at home or overseas. We mourn for all whose hearts are rent by the
seven swords of the loss of a loved one. Let us be assured that, for God, “all of them
are alive”, they are all held in God’s loving embrace, just as certainly as those who
mourn their loss are also loved – for we are assured that nothing, neither life not death,
“nor anything else in all creation can separate us from the love of God in Christ Jesus,
our Lord” (Rom. 8:38-39).
Let us pray -
Holy One, we have come before you this Remembrance Sunday with praise and
thanksgiving, and also with sorrow in our hearts. With gratitude, we call to mind the
soldiers, sailors, air personnel, and the RCMP, who have paid the ultimate price so that
we might live in freedom. We remember those who died in distant wars and those who
have lost their lives more recently, even close to home. By their sacrifice, we are called
to continue their work for peace, to keep the torch held high. May their valour and
selflessness never be forgotten; may we be worthy of their sacrifice.
Amen.