Sunday, November 7th, 2021 – Remembrance Sunday
Philip’s Reflection: “Answering the Call” (Matt. 5:1-12)
“Remember” is one of those words in the English language that is full of different
meanings depending on context – for example “commemorate”, “get”, “learn”, “look
back”, “recall”, “recognize”, “relive”, “remind”. As we reflect on the meaning of
“Remembrance” – Remembrance Day this Thursday, 11th day of the eleventh month, or
today – “Remembrance Sunday” at St. David’s, it’s helpful to know that the word
“remember” is formed from two Latin words – “re” (which means “again”) and
“memorari” (meaning “to be mindful of”) – so “to remember” is literally “to be mindful of
again” or “to bring to mind again”.
And this is what we do each Remembrance Day – it’s the day we “bring to mind again”.
And after 18 months like no other in our lifetimes, there’s more than usual we could be
mindful of today. The sight of the Maple Leaf brings to mind that for the past 6 months
Canada’s national flag has been flying at half-mast on all government buildings,
following the discovery of the unmarked graves of children at the former Residential
Schools. The flag will be raised again today. The face-masks remind us that we are still
in a global pandemic that has claimed over 5 million lives worldwide and over 2,200
deaths here in B.C, among 200,000 cases. The candles bring to mind those who have
gone before us, particularly during this past year, loved ones, saints, good people, all
those who have blessed our lives. May they rest at peace.
In Canada, and the Commonwealth countries, Remembrance Day has a more
intentional purpose – as the day when we “bring to mind again” all those who have
served this country, then and now, and particularly those who died in conflict, sacrificing
their lives for the ideals of peace and freedom and justice for all the people of this
country. We bring to mind the 66,000 Canadians and Newfoundlanders killed during
WW1, approximately 1 in 10 of all Canadians in uniform, and the further 172,000
severely wounded, often with dreadful injuries, sustained in the trenches, loss of limbs,
shell-shock and the poison of mustard gas – a reminder, lest we forget, that there is
absolutely nothing romantic about war; and we are also mindful of the 45,000
Canadians who gave their lives in WW2 and the 55,000 seriously wounded – and in
other armed conflicts since then, most recently the 158 Canadian servicemen and
women killed in combat in Afghanistan, and the hundreds more maimed, traumatized
and suffering from PTSD. Canada has paid a heavy price, during our young life as a
nation, for the commitment to freedom and democracy.
“Remembering” is not a neutral or dispassionate activity and for each of us the act of
remembrance stirs many emotions. The first and most obvious is one of gratitude – and
we say to veterans “we honour you”, and all the servicemen and women, particularly
those known to us, who served and are serving; and we honour especially the war
dead, the wounded and all those who still suffer the loss of loved ones or of lifechanging
injury. As people of faith, we give thanks to God for their sacrifices, as we also
pray for wholeness and reconciliation.
And, each year, as we again bring these young men and women to mind, we are filled
with deep sorrow for the destructive effects of war, and we need to be reminded again
and again of the sheer scale of human loss in two World Wars, particularly in the
indiscriminate and disproportionate effect on civilian populations – for over half of the 41
million lives lost in WW1 were civilians; in WWII, approximately 45 million of the 60
million fatalities, around three quarters, were civilian, men, women and children. The
proportion of civilian casualties in warfare is even higher today – and, as we see each
evening on our tv screens, wars in several parts of the world continue to cause
appalling suffering, trauma, famine and human displacement.
And with the gratitude, the honouring, and the sorrow, and a recognition of the
continuing, devastating effects of military conflict – also come many troubling questions:
would we have answered the call in the same way that so many of our forebears did;
indeed, what is the nature of that call; more generally, will we ever learn from the
history, or are we doomed to repeat the mistakes of the past until some appalling
miscalculation by one of the nuclear powers places all of our lives at risk; surely, there
are enough existential threats to the future of all of God’s creation, without adding the
threat of nuclear war?
This is one of the values of a day like this when, as we bring to mind again and again,
the scale of destruction caused by modern warfare, we are forced to confront important
questions about our future, both as individuals and also as a nation. As I’ve suggested,
“remembering” is not a neutral activity – not least because, as we know, history tends to
be written by the winners. But nor is it an activity that concerns only the past. Perhaps
even more importantly for us today, and for our children, and future generations, is how
we are to interpret the past – this annual act of bringing to mind therefore has a future
dimension. And it is to this future, towards a more peaceable and just future, that Dr.
John McRae is referring when he writes that “we throw the torch; be yours to hold it
high. [And] if ye break faith with us who die, we shall not sleep”.
In the Christian tradition, we interpret the past, and we consider the future, through the
lens of the teaching and life, death and resurrection of our Lord, Jesus Christ. There is
perhaps no better expression of this teaching than in the passage we just heard read
from the Gospel of Matthew, known as the Beatitudes – it’s the start of the longer
discourse known as the Sermon on the Mount. Matthew presents Jesus as the new
Moses – like Moses, he emerges from Egypt to liberate an oppressed Israel, wanders in
the wilderness, relies on God for sustenance, and now teaches from a mountain.
However, the Beatitudes are not new Commandments - they are not rules. Jesus does
not require or glorify poverty of spirit, or mourning or hunger or persecution as the path
towards receiving God’s blessings.
The Beatitudes contain Jesus’ teaching, addressed to the disciples, and describe his
vision of a world that is aligned with God’s concerns – the kingdom of heaven is the
promise of communal wholeness, in which the afflicted and oppressed will be liberated
and blessed. It is a kind of manifesto for God’s community in which there is no poverty,
either materially or spiritually; or injustice, or war or persecution; it’s a world where the
mourning are comforted and where God’s mercy and blessing are received, particularly
by the poor and the sick and the meek, and those who have suffered for righteousness’
sake. And importantly on this day of Remembrance, Jesus speaks of a community in
which the peacemakers are blessed, “for they will be called children of God.”
We have described “remembrance” as the act of “bringing to mind again” and today is
the day when we honour in gratitude all those who have answered the call to serve this
country and, especially today, those who lost their lives for the sake of peace, and
freedom from tyranny and oppression. We have also been reminded of a future
dimension of remembering, how we are to interpret the past to ensure a better future for
all people, in fact for the flourishing of all of God’s creation. The Beatitudes give us a
lens through which to imagine such a world, one where we are at peace with ourselves,
with each other in community, and with other nations; and it is a world in which there is
an inseparable connection between peace and justice. It is a compelling vision, not only
for those who view the world through the lens of the living Christ, but for all of God’s
creation. And it is a vision in which “peacekeeping” has a key role to play.
Do you remember that famous recruiting poster from WWI – it shows a picture of Lord
Kitchener, then the British Secretary of War, fixing you with a stare and pointing a finger
at you – “Your country needs you” it reads – and we know that hundreds of thousands
of young British and Canadian men and women, including many from the Indigenous
communities, answered that call; and we will always remember their sacrifice. We will
not break their faith; and today is the day we recommit ourselves to answering God’s
call, to advocate and work for a more just and peaceful world, the vision that Jesus
described to the first disciples, and which still today offers us a glimpse of the kingdom
of heaven. Your country still needs you; and, even more importantly, God needs you, in
the work of building the kingdom on earth, as it is in heaven. That is surely the faithful
way in which to honour the war dead. Let us each, as we can, answer that noble call.
Amen.
November 7th, 2021