Sunday, August 14th, 2022 – Children’s Sunday
Philip’s Reflection: “The Unfruitful Vineyard” (Isaiah 5:1-7)
Here in the United Church of Canada, we believe that Scripture is to be taken seriously
but not literally – our most recent Statement of Faith describes Scripture as:
“our song for the journey, the living word
passed on from generation to generation
to guide and inspire,
that we might wrestle a holy revelation for our time and place”
- “the living word”… to “guide and inspire” – in other words, the Bible isn’t some type of
fossilized curiosity that we view in a museum or a public library – but a living organism,
from which, through the power of the Holy Spirit, we may hear and understand what
God is saying to us that is relevant to our context, here, now and for all time. So what
“guidance” and “inspiration” can we wrestle from our Old Testament reading today?
At one level, Isaiah’s “Song of the Vineyard” is an agricultural story expressed in familiar
terms for the 8th century BCE audiences to whom it was addressed. The Prophet
Isaiah’s beloved friend owns a vineyard. It’s set in a prime grape-growing location, with
rich soil on the side of a hill. The owner carefully prepares it for planting - clears it of
rocks and stones and plants the very best vines, builds a protective watchtower and a
perfect wine press. And the owner of course expects the vineyard to yield nothing but
the finest grapes for fine wine, VQA wine. But instead it yields “rotten grapes”, sour
grapes (Is. 5:1-2). And turning to the audience, the owner now asks “What more was
there to do for my vineyard that I have not done in it?” (5:3) – what more could I possibly
have done? We hear frustration and anger in his voice – “And now I will tell you what I
will do to my vineyard” (5:5) – I will remove the protective hedges and break down the
walls, the vines will be overcome and overgrown by weeds and thorns and the vineyard
that I have loved and cared for will become nothing more than a parched wasteland.
And this is why we take Scripture “seriously but not literally” – because, in the final
verse, the prophet explains that the owner of the vineyard is to be understood as God,
and the kingdoms of Israel and Judah are the vineyard and God’s cherished garden –
the people had every opportunity to produce a bountiful harvest but they produced
rotten fruit – instead of a just society, they delivered violence and oppression, instead of
seeing righteousness, God hears only the cries of the oppressed. An angry and
disappointed God, the owner of the vineyard judges, punishes and rejects the people for
their infidelity, their misuse of God-given privileges, their squandering of potential.
We struggle with a passage like this - for what does it reveal about the nature of God;
does this type of carrot and stick God really inspire us to live our lives today as God
would want – seeking justice, loving kindness and walking humbly (Micah 6:8)? And
what meaning does it have for a community such as ours which, like the vineyard, has
been blessed with the abundance of God’s goodness – choice vines in fertile soil?
We’re all more comfortable, perhaps, with questions such as these than the answers
but the meaning of the passage seems clear – in fact Isaiah tells us it to us like it is -
that the God revealed in this Song is a God who longs for social justice but beholds
injustice; a God who expects righteousness (communal or individual morality) but who
hears the cries of the oppressed. We love the vineyard owner’s meticulous cultivation of
the vineyard, as the expression of God’s care for God’s people. But we’re also shocked,
aren’t we, to read how this same God, in frustration or anger, systematically removes
the hedges, breaks down its walls and tramples the vines, leaving the vineyard uncared
for and overgrown with weeds and thorns?
The Good News, as followers of Jesus, is that we find answers to some of these
questions in the New Testament, for we read there that “Christ Jesus came into the
world to save sinners” (1 Tim 1:15) and that “God did not send the Son into the world to
condemn the world but in order that the world might be saved through him” (Jn 3:17).
And it is our Saviour, Jesus, that we encounter in our second Scripture reading – and
we now hear of Jesus rebuking the disciples for preventing people from bringing little
children to him, so they could be blessed. Watch out, says Mark, Jesus is “indignant”
and Jesus orders the disciples in no uncertain terms to let the children come to him “for
the kingdom of God belongs to such as these… anyone who will not receive the
kingdom of God like a little child will never enter it.” (Mk. 10:15).
As in Isaiah’s Song of the Vineyard, we recognize in Jesus God’s preferential treatment
for the weakest and most vulnerable in society – even more so in those days when on a
scale of 1-10 on the social ladder, children were close to zero. Like the vineyard owner,
Jesus expected, and demonstrated, justice and blessing for those on the margins of
society, including the children. Jesus doesn’t say we need to become a child to enter
the kingdom of God – and that’s a relief for those of us in the later years of our lives. But
yes, Jesus is saying, I believe, that the qualities we often associate with children - of
dependence, perhaps even utter dependence; of trust, perhaps even complete trust;
and of spontaneity and acceptance, rather than calculation or skepticism, are the keys
to enter the kingdom. We won’t be sentimental and extol the benefits of a simple, childlike faith; but we must also be careful not to over-think our faith, or we will fall into that
well-known trap of “paralysis by over-analysis”.
Jesus tells us that the kingdom of God “belongs to such as these”, such as the little
children. We are to welcome the kingdom of God as we would welcome a child, as
Jesus does – with open arms and an open heart. That also applies to us as a
community – as we think about how we welcome children, how we welcome all who are
vulnerable and marginalized, into our life and work and worship - what language we
use, what songs we sing and yes, how we tell the stories of Jesus. With God’s grace,
we will build a community where all are welcome, of all ages, cultures and identities, a
diverse and joyful community where all are loved for who and whose we are, as God’s
children, all of us, a community that is planted in fertile soil, with the choicest vines
producing a harvest that will be truly pleasing to the Lord. May it be so.
Amen.