May 30, 2021 - A WALK IN THE DARK - Rev. Dal McCrindleWhen I was in Scouts, decades ago, we used to intersperseyells and skits between our camp fire songs. Do any of youremember that old campfire skit where people are divided into twogroups and one shouts to the other, “Old Bill bought a boat!” Andthe responding group shouts back, “What, Old Bill Baily bought agoat?” ”No,” shouts the first group, “Old Bill Baily bought a boat!”they repeat the statement. “What,” shouts the second grouplouder than the first time, “Old Bill Bailey caught a cold?” No,”shouts the first groups louder than either their first question andthe response by the second group, “Old Bill Bailey bought a boat!”“What,” once again they shout their query, “Old Bill Bailey cut histhroat?” “No,” shouts the first group, knowing that they’re nevergoing to communicate their informative news about Bill Bailey andacquiesce to their failure, “Yeah he cut his bloomin’ head off!”So often people and or groups talk to each other but arestymied because of communication problems. Even when they shoutas loud as possible, their messages fly past each other like thegarbled words of a scout camp-fire skit.The encounter of Nicodemus with Jesus reminded me ofthat old scout skit and the fun we used to have doing it, trying tosee who could out shout the other. Of course, at Scout Camp, thepurpose wasn’t to communicate anything about Old Bill Bailey. Theobject was to make more noise than the other side, even to thepoint of scaring every living creature in the forest for at least 10miles around!Here we heard about Jesus and Nicodemus talking to eachother on different planes. It’s not that they cannot hear oneanother or are confused by the words. They hear each other’swords but don’t understand what they are talking about.Nicodemus comes to Jesus, “at night” an important factorin itself and seeks out this rabbi. Maybe, he thinks, this youngpreacher from Galilee will dazzle him more with some miraculousdeed that will transform his way of thinking and believing. Butimmediately they encounter a communication problem.Jesus declares that in order to understand the signs of the kingdom ofGod, you have to be born from above. Nicodemus thinks in termsof being born all over again and he wonders the biology of all that.He thinks that faith is simply a matter of tracking the signs andweighing the evidence and drawing logical conclusions. “What do Ihave to do?” “Oh, good, I can do that; seems clear and simplyenough. There’s no need of risk, no need for uncertainty: just listall the positives and see if the list of positives is longer than thenegatives. It’s easy to make decisions this way.” That’s the thingabout Nicodemus, he’s looking for the easy way but decisions aboutfaith are not made that way. Faith requires an act of God, anaction from above, not simply gathering more data.Nicodemus reminds me of the time when, then PM PierreElliott Trudeau went for a walk. Remember him? His popularity hadbeen fading and some inside their party were sharpening theirpolitical pruning knives. So, he went for a walk, during a snowstorm, during the night. The newspaper reports of that twilightwalk sounded almost scriptural, at least poetic. They reported that“the Prime Minister went for a walk.” Now, that would haverevealed one thing. Maybe that there wasn’t anything good on TVthat night, but to add “at night, in the snow,” added a sense ofmystery, a sense of spiritual things. Stormy nights are when weirdthings transpire, when the gods are close to the earth, wheninexplicable events take shape. Who hasn’t set down to write theirworld class novel with the opening line, “once on a stormy night.”Daytime, people can see, nighttime is the time of darkness ofshadows, unclarity, deceit, trickery and danger.Nicodemus comes to Jesus, at night. He has seen enough orheard enough to pursue this guy from Galilee, but only under thecloak of secrecy, darkness. Nicomedus is a man in transition; he’sa Pharisee, a leader in the Jewish community who has beenattracted to Jesus because of signs and miracles. But Jesus islooking for greater depth. He doesn’t want people to follow whoare only interested because of “bread and miracles.” Jesus islooking for those who have been transformed, who haveexperienced a total about face, a conversion, having been bornagain! Later on, we find this very same Nicodemus courageouslyspeaking out in defense of Jesus and finally joining with anotherdisciples in preparing Jesus’ body for burial. Knowing this, ourpassage marks the early progress in Nicodemus’ pilgrimage frombystander to disciple, from not knowing to profound faith.But this passage can also be viewed in another way. It canbe viewed as a parable of conflict between the church and itsopponents. In order to see this, we must realize that at the timeof the encounter with Jesus, Nicodemus was the enemy. Heapproaches Jesus, “as leader of the Jews,” which for John means“an opponent.” And it is not only the fact that Nicodemus is a Jewthat makes him a foe, for Jesus is Jewish as well, but rather thefact that he represents the established power, those who claim toknow God, but in reality, don’t! Seen this way, the dialoguebetween Jesus and Nicodemus mirrors the kind of dailyconfrontations that John’s church experienced and that we too,might experience.People all around them — religious authorities, theirfamilies, their neighbours and friends — were confused andtroubled by this new faith. Over and over they challenged them,asking the same question that Nicodemus asks, “How can this be?”And Jesus responds by saying that one cannot stand outside of theSpirit’s realm and understand life in the spirit. The spirit is not anobject to be scrutinized, a doctrine to be learned and recited. Thespirit is a life-giving force, a power that surges wild and free.Only those caught up in the spirit’s life-giving power can know whatthe life of the Spirit is all about.Many are attracted to Jesus as was Nicodemus, like a mothto the light, looking for simply answers, something they can grasponto that will quickly provide solutions and directions to life’sconfusion. Our culture is always trying to break religiousexperiences down into something manageable, less mysterious, morecontrollable. But we cannot. Society, sometimes observes prayer,serving and giving thanks to God but are persuaded that when weget to the bottom of it all, it really is all about self-fulfillment,or greed, or deception, or habit, or control, or neurosis, or as KarlMarx declared an opiate for the people. The church is often notseen in a very good light. Why on earth, or in heaven would anyonewant to be part of such a dysfunctional band of folk?You claim to have changed your life, but how can this be?You say, you are a new person, but that’s not really possible. Aleopard cannot change its spots. Born anew, my foot. “Old BillBailey cut his throat is the message they hear!” Our words aregarbled and our pronouncements are often on the wrong plain.We’re seen as the same old people with a little piety lathered on.Is our transformation, our conversion evident? Or are we seen asborn from above, living God’s Spirit?Jesus speaks of spirit, Nicodemus hears only ‘the flesh.’The world cannot truly understand what has happened to thefollowers of Jesus, while parents, friends, religious authorities andothers badger them constantly, “and what’s happened to you? Whydon’t you believe the same things we do any longer? How do youexplain your behaviour?” In many ways they and we, “speak ofwhat we know and testify to what we have seen.”For John’s church, their experience was their defense. Tothe establishment, they did not expound philosophical theories,theological arguments or scientific proofs. They simply testified towhat they had seen; the Samaritan woman did that, the man bornblind did that, as did Nicodemus.So why did they or we do what we do? Because the Spirithas spoken from above and lives are a witness to what has beenexperienced. So, go for a walk in the night. Seek him out andwhen the light comes into the world, the darkness can neverovercome it. Want proof? There’s none, but we could askNicodemus, the leader of the old way, who becomes a follower ofthe new, a disciple of the light. How can this be?” Surely someonemust have asked him and with a shrug, similar to that of Trudeauhe probably replied, “I can only speak of what I know. The windblows where it wills and so it is with everyone born of the spirit.”At least that’s the way I see it!
St. David's United Church, West Vancouver